Original Ad Analysis:

I found this ad online, a site called HHSMiaNako. This ad was effective because of the use of color, placement of the ad content, the author said she believes the use of contrasting colors in the background was bold and nice to look at but it wasn’t too distracting to the main subject; the hydro flask since the hydro flask’s color was also very contrasting to the background. This AD immediately caught my attention because I thought it was so creative. Then I decided to do this ad.
https://sites.google.com/site/hhsmianako/home/photography
Design

Contrast
I like how she chose really different two pictures as the background. One is a volcano, the other an iceberg. The author makes clever use of the contrast between icebergs and volcanoes. The colors are also contrasting, but not too dramatic to draw attention to the background rather than the glass. I really like it.
Proximity

This part is amazing. I didn’t notice that the first time I saw it. When I took more time to look at it, I was amazed. The two pictures are a perfect match together. It’s very creative and it makes the background a little less obtrusive.
Color
The main colors in the picture are black, white and brown. They went really well together in this picture. I think It’s really interested to see the author chose to use the black Hydro Flask water bottle. We know there are so many different colors in Hydro Flask water bottle. Then I found out the black is the best color in between as a transfer color.
Typography
The type style is sans serif. There’s a lot of elements in the background, plus the cup in the middle of the picture, which is pretty full. The author chose not to have any serifs and thick/thin transition in the strokes. Also, she used different colors to show the contrast.
New Ad Analysis:

Design
Same idea, but I changed the background pictures to jungle and dessert. I want to show how the water bottle can hydrate our life. When I was picking my pictures, I deliberately chose some photos with some white space on the top of them. Also, the shapes are really similar.
Contrast

I chose the desert and jungle to be my background. They are a pretty big contrast. One is really green and wet. However, the desert is really dry so you can feel a big difference.
Proximity

I did the same way for my background pictures. I matched them together. Also, the cap of this water bottle looks like a small mountain. I hope this helped them to combine together well.
Color

I chose to use this big red Hydro Flask water bottle. Red, brown and green, I think they matched really well. I really want to show my focus is the water bottle, not something else.
Typography
I chose the sans serif style also. No serifs and thick/thin transition in the strokes which makes really simple and clear. I put the opposite colors on them also.
Conclusion
We used the same product, Hydro Flask water bottle. Same idea, but I changed to a different background. I want to show how this can hydrate our lives in different situations, so I chose the jungle and desert. The original one used volcano and iceberg. The messages we want to deliver are really similar. That’s why they can work together for the same campaign.












